AD8302ARUZ-RL7 vs AD8304ARUZ

Bảng so sánh chi tiết giữa AD8302ARUZ-RL7 và AD8304ARUZ cung cấp những thông tin giá trị về thông số kỹ thuật và các tính năng chính của chúng. Chúng tôi đề cập chi tiết đến các yếu tố quan trọng, bao gồm tuân thủ RoHS, trạng thái REACH, dòng sản phẩm, kiểu lắp đặt, loại bao bì và các đặc điểm liên quan khác. Việc trình bày sự khác biệt cạnh nhau giúp đơn giản hóa việc lựa chọn linh kiện, giúp bạn dễ dàng chọn được tùy chọn tốt nhất cho ứng dụng cụ thể của mình.

Technical review by ETEI Component Engineering Source: manufacturer documentation

Replacement verdict

Not a drop-in replacement

The AD8304ARUZ and AD8302ARUZ-RL7 are not interchangeable despite sharing the same TSSOP-14 package and similar supply voltage ranges. The AD8304ARUZ is a single-channel logarithmic detector optimized for fiber-optic photodiode measurement with a 160 dB dynamic range, while the AD8302ARUZ-RL7 is a dual-channel gain and phase detector intended for RF/IF signal analysis. Their core functions, input architectures, and output signal types differ fundamentally, so neither part can directly substitute for the other in an existing design.

Different core function Different channel count Different output type Different input architecture

Parts at a glance

Part A

AD8302ARUZ-RL7

Công ty Analog Devices Inc.

Lifecycle
Active
Stock
2916 PCS
Package
TSSOP-14
Series
RF Detectors
Part B

AD8304ARUZ

Công ty Analog Devices Inc.

Lifecycle
Active
Stock
2339 PCS
Package
TSSOP-14
Series
Linear - Amplifiers - Special Purpose

Key differences

Rows are prioritized by design impact. Highlighted values require attention during substitution.

Key electrical and mechanical differences between the two devices

Parameter AD8304ARUZ AD8302ARUZ-RL7 Why it matters
Function Logarithmic converter (log amp) RF gain/phase detector These are fundamentally different signal-processing functions, so they are not functionally substitutable in most designs.
Frequency Range DC to 160 MHz (input bandwidth) DC to 2.7 GHz The operating frequency range determines whether the part can handle the signal bandwidth of the target application.
Primary Output Logarithmic voltage proportional to input Gain (magnitude ratio) and phase difference voltages The output type defines what the downstream circuitry can measure and how the part integrates into a system.
Dynamic Range ~80 dB (logarithmic) ~60 dB (gain measurement) Dynamic range sets the span of signal levels the device can accurately process without saturation or loss of resolution.
Number of Channels 1 2 (dual input for ratio/phase) Channel count affects whether the device can perform differential or ratio-based measurements required for gain/phase detection.
Supply Voltage 3.0 V to 5.5 V 2.7 V to 5.5 V Supply voltage compatibility determines whether the part can operate within the system's available power rails.
Package 16-lead TSSOP 14-lead TSSOP Package and pin count affect PCB footprint and layout compatibility for drop-in substitution.
Operating Temperature Range -40 °C to +85 °C -40 °C to +85 °C The temperature range confirms suitability for the intended environment; identical ranges here ease environmental qualification.

Need help validating a replacement?

Send your BOM and application constraints for technical and sourcing review.

Full specification comparison

Use manufacturer datasheets as the final authority.

Specification AD8302ARUZ-RL7 AD8304ARUZ
Part Status Active Active
Frequency 2.7GHz -
RF Type General Purpose -
Input Range -60dBm ~ 0dBm -
Accuracy ±0.5dB -
Voltage - Supply 2.7V ~ 5.5V -
Supply Current 23 mA -
Mounting Type Surface Mount Surface Mount
Type - Logarithmic Converter
Applications - Fiber Optics

Frequently asked questions

What are the primary functions of the AD8304ARUZ and AD8302ARUZ-RL7?

The AD8304ARUZ is a logarithmic amplifier (log amp) optimized for measuring optical power in fiber-optic applications, providing a linear-in-dB output over a wide dynamic range. The AD8302ARUZ-RL7 is a gain and phase detector that measures the amplitude ratio and phase difference between two input signals, intended for RF/IF power amplifier linearization and return loss measurement.

Are the AD8304ARUZ and AD8302ARUZ-RL7 pin-compatible or interchangeable?

No. Although both are offered in a 14-lead TSSOP package (RU suffix), they have different internal architectures and pin functions. The AD8304 is a single-channel logarithmic detector, while the AD8302 integrates dual logarithmic amplifiers, a phase detector, and output scaling circuitry. They are not direct substitutes and require separate evaluation against the target design.

What is the specified operating frequency range for each device?

The AD8304ARUZ is specified for operation from DC to 10 MHz, making it suitable for low-frequency optical power monitoring. The AD8302ARUZ-RL7 is specified for operation from DC to 2.7 GHz, covering RF and IF measurement applications.

How do the output interfaces of the two parts differ?

The AD8304ARUZ provides a single logarithmic voltage output proportional to the input current, with a nominal slope of 10 mV/dB and a specified intercept. The AD8302ARUZ-RL7 provides two outputs: a gain output (VMAG) proportional to the log ratio of the two input amplitudes and a phase output (VPHS) proportional to the phase difference, each with independently specified scaling.

What are the supply voltage and temperature range specifications?

Both devices operate from a single supply in the range of 2.7 V to 5.5 V. The AD8304ARUZ is specified over the industrial temperature range of −40°C to +85°C. The AD8302ARUZ-RL7 is specified over the −40°C to +85°C industrial range as well. Designers should confirm exact limits in the respective manufacturer datasheets.

Which device should be selected for optical power measurement versus RF gain/phase measurement?

For optical power monitoring, the AD8304ARUZ is the appropriate choice because its logarithmic response is optimized for photodiode current input over a wide dynamic range. For RF/IF gain and phase measurement, such as in power amplifier linearization or VSWR/return loss monitoring, the AD8302ARUZ-RL7 is the appropriate choice because it provides simultaneous magnitude and phase outputs.

Do the AD8304ARUZ and AD8302ARUZ-RL7 share the same package and PCB land pattern?

Both are supplied in a 14-lead TSSOP (RU) package, so the package outline and land pattern are the same. However, because the pin functions differ between the two devices, a board designed for one part cannot be populated with the other without verifying the pin assignments and surrounding circuitry.

What are the key dynamic range specifications for each part?

The AD8304ARUZ provides a logarithmic dynamic range of approximately 80 dB for input currents from about 100 pA to 1 mA, depending on configuration. The AD8302ARUZ-RL7 provides a gain measurement range of approximately ±30 dB and a phase measurement range of 0° to 180°, with specified accuracy over its 2.7 GHz bandwidth. Exact limits should be taken from the manufacturer datasheets.